Reviews for Linksys Instant Gigabit EG008W Ethernet Switch

8 x 10/100/1000Base-T - MPN: EG008W

  • 3
  By member: MrGeode - Jun 20, 2006

Accepable home 1000BaseTX switch

Strengths: Stackable with other Linksys devices

Weakness: noisy fan and runs hot

I upgrade my home network to 1000BaseTX last year. The unit does a very nice job if you can live with the heat. The switch runs hot even with a fan. I had to install it on the top of my network stack so as to not cook anything. The fan started to get noisy about a month after I installed it. I can hear the unit's fan over the fans in my computer. Linksys could have used higher quality fans.

100% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
  • 2
  By anonymous - May 11, 2007

Died in less than 2 years

Strengths: Easy to set up, very fast transfer speeds

Weakness: Purchased in June 2005, Died May 2007 - RIP Linksys Gigabit Switch

I miss the old days when electronic devices were built to last...those slow, ancient 10-base switches are still working decades later. This switch is being replaced by a 3com or D-Link product with a lifetime warranty (because I'm sure it will be needed!)

100% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
  • 1
  By member: sifuchar - Mar 23, 2006

Have gone through 2 in four months

Strengths: Good case design for stackability, good performance

Weakness: Fan noise, heat, prone to failure

I bought both this and the 5-port version. The 5-port doesn't have a fan and is much cooler. For some reason the 8-port generates a lot of heat and must be fan-cooled.

Worked great for 2 months (not stacked) then suddenly quit. Linksys replaced it, which covered me for another 2 months until the obviously USED replacement quit. I have just completed month 1 of the replacement for the replacement, and so far so good.

Although I was able to get Linksys to replace the unit twice, the process was incredibly long and frustrating. They don't just give you an RMA number, you have to go through their website and enter your case number. The case number is supposed to be sent to you in an email after you talk to tech support. To get my case number took me approximately 7 phone calls, 4 hours of my time, and endless repetition of the story to idiots at tech support trying to see if they could make my existing unit work (for crying out loud, it's a SWITCH! It has no controls, only lights, with ceased to work when it stopped carrying network traffic!). Everyone at tech support was very interested to determine when exactly I purchased the original unit, even when I was calling to return the replacement unit when it died.

Anyway, Linksys has a good reputation and most of their products are good, but I cannot recommend this unit. Due to the problems with tech support, I am hesitant to recommend Linksys at all.

83% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
Reply by member: MrGeode
Jun 20, 2006

The 5-port version, EG005W, also has a fan, but runs cooler. The fan in the EG005W I got 14 months ago is just as loud as the fan in the EG008W I got at the same time.

  • 3
  By member: dmbpcnet - Feb 18, 2004

Linksys Instant Gigabit EG008W Ethernet Switch

Strengths: Home GIGABiTE Switch

Weakness: Hot and Loud

Performs acceptability However, I bought one when they were first released.
I was disappointed in the heat generation and NOISE!
The fan is loud and rattles - VERY irritatiing.

73% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
  • 2
  By member: rcc1123 - Apr 16, 2004

Linksys Instant Gigabit EG008W Ethernet Switch

Strengths: Small and compact

Weakness: very noisy and generates WAY too much heat

Beware of this unit. It is NOT stackable due to the amount of heat it generates. My unit has basically toasted itself in the two plus months I've had it even though it had more than adequate airflow surrounding it. I will not replace it with the same unit.

67% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top
  • 5
  By member: kintama - Jan 16, 2004

Linksys Instant Gigabit EG008W Ethernet Switch

Strengths: Fast file transfer, easy setup and usage.

Weakness: none

I do not understand why some people say this is a noisy switch. Yes it does have a cooling fan but it is not loud. Over all this is an Excellent product that I will buy again if I need more ports.

43% of readers found this review helpful. Did you find it helpful or unhelpful?

Top